top of page

The Defender, BYD and the Difficult Business of Owning a Shape

4 days ago
10 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

An automotive dispute brings one of the hardest questions in intellectual property law into focus: where does design protection end and freedom of competition begin?


Jaguar Land Rover has decided to take BYD to the Dutch courts, claiming that the design of the new Ti7 unlawfully reproduces that of the Land Rover Defender.


Looking at photographs of the two vehicles, the source of the dispute is clear. Their proportions, boxy bodywork, rooflines and certain side-panel details appear noticeably similar. You do not have to be an automotive design expert to see it.


The problem is that, fortunately, intellectual property law does not grant an exclusive right to everything that is recognisable, nor does it automatically transform an aesthetic similarity into a design infringement.


And this is precisely what makes the controversy interesting, well beyond the events of the two manufacturers.


Intellectual property and the problem of shape

Design protection occupies a very particular position in the industrial property system, because it protects something that does not fully coincide with any of the other major categories of exclusive rights.


A patent protects a technical solution, provided it meets the requirements of novelty, inventive step, and industrial applicability. It does not protect the appearance of a product as such, but rather the invention that enables a specific result to be achieved.


A trade mark, on the other hand, serves an essentially distinctive function: it allows the public to identify the commercial origin of products and services. A trade mark doesn't need to be particularly beautiful, original, or the product of creative effort. It just needs to be capable of distinguishing.


Design occupies a different position. It protects the external appearance of a product, resulting from its lines, contours, shape, colors, materials, and other visible features. It does not require a technical invention, nor does it require the public to necessarily identify a specific company through that shape.

This is where the difficulties arise.

Granting an exclusive right to a shape means temporarily denying competitors expressive and design options. But that same shape could derive from functional needs, established industry conventions, stylistic trends, or a combination of already-known elements.


The law must therefore identify what deserves protection without transforming the common aesthetic heritage of a sector into a series of private properties.


In the case of cars, the issue is particularly clear. An off-road vehicle may have a boxy body, a high hood, pronounced wheel arches, and a vertical cockpit for functional, stylistic, or both reasons. These are features found, in varying combinations, in the Defender, the Mercedes G-Class, the Toyota Land Cruiser, and numerous other vehicles.

No one can claim to own the very idea of a square car.

However, it can claim the protection of a specific formal configuration, if the requirements established by law are met.

And distinguishing the two situations is not at all simple.


What exactly does EU design law protect?

The matter is currently governed by Regulation (EU) 2026/715 , in force since 1 July 2026, which codifies the European legislation on designs after the recent reform.

Articles 5, 6 and 7 require two fundamental conditions: novelty and individual character .

Novelty ceases when an identical design has already been disclosed, subject to the exceptions provided by law. Individual character, on the other hand, requires that the design produce an overall impression on the informed user that is different from that produced by prior designs.


It's a crucial distinction. Two products may not be identical, and thus pass the initial test, but still be too similar to justify a new exclusive.


Article 11 then uses the same parameter to determine the extent of protection: the owner can oppose designs that do not convey a different overall impression to the informed user.


Judgment, therefore, isn't limited to identifying a few similarities. It's necessary to consider the overall impression and the designer's freedom.


This last point introduces a further difficulty: when a product's characteristics are strongly influenced by technical requirements, even relatively small differences can become more significant. However, when the designer has extensive freedom, marginal variations may prove insufficient.


However, we must not confuse actual constraints with mere market habits. The fact that consumers expect a certain shape does not necessarily mean that the designer was obligated to create it.


There is also an often overlooked aspect: the EUIPO registers designs without conducting a thorough preliminary examination of their novelty and individual character. Registration, therefore, does not definitively certify the substantive validity of the right. This verification can occur later, including through invalidity proceedings.


The Porsche 911 paradox: too much like itself

One of the most interesting precedents is represented by the judgment of the General Court of the European Union of 6 June 2019, case T-209/18 , relating to the design of the Porsche 911.


Porsche had registered the design of the 991 series. The problem was that the model retained a very strong stylistic continuity with the previous 997 series.


This continuity, of course, constituted an enormous commercial asset. The Porsche 911 is recognisable precisely because, across generations, it has maintained its own aesthetic identity.

From a legal perspective, however, the issue took on a different perspective.

The Court confirmed the invalidity of the registered design of series 991 due to its lack of individual character compared to the previous model. The changes made were not sufficient to produce a different overall impression on the informed user.

This is a very instructive precedent.

The stylistic continuity that makes a product recognisable on the market can become the main obstacle to registering a new design.


And the problem isn't just theoretical. If it were enough to periodically update a few details to obtain a new exclusive right to the general layout of a product, the limited duration of design protection would risk being circumvented.


The European legislator has established a maximum term of twenty-five years for registered designs, with five-year renewals. The possibility of indefinitely protecting the same shape through subsequent, nearly identical registrations would contradict the very logic of the system.


The Porsche controversy also had a very concrete side: on the other side was a manufacturer of model cars.


Even reproducing a car to scale can therefore turn into a controversy over the validity of an industrial design.


When a design becomes a trade mark: the Vespa case

The position changes when prolonged use and public recognition give a product's shape an additional function: it no longer merely represents the appearance of an object but identifies a particular commercial origin.

This is the phenomenon of three-dimensional brands. A striking example is the Vespa.

On 22 July 2026, the EUIPO granted registration of the shape of the Vespa Primavera as a three-dimensional trade mark, recognising its distinctive character acquired through use.


The public doesn't just recognize a scooter by its distinctive lines. They recognize those features as a specific commercial origin, regardless of whether the name Piaggio or Vespa is present.


The 2026 registration is particularly interesting because it concerns a stylistic evolution of the Vespa, not simply the re-introduction of a historic model.


In this case, the shape manages to cross the line between design and brand, but not because it's aesthetically successful. It crosses it because it has acquired a demonstrable distinctiveness.

The difference is fundamental.

A design is protected because it is new and individual. A trade mark is protected because it is distinctive. And, unlike the former, it can be renewed without a predetermined time limit, as long as the conditions for protection persist.


Of course, simply applying for a three-dimensional trade mark is not enough to obtain a permanent monopoly on a shape.


Article 7, paragraph 1, letter e) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 excludes, among other things, shapes dictated by the nature of the product, those necessary to achieve a technical result, and those that confer substantial value to the product. These exclusions cannot be overcome even by demonstrating distinctive character acquired through use.


The system thus seeks to prevent the trade mark from being used to perpetuate exclusive rights that should instead have a limited duration.


Coca-Cola and Bang & Olufsen: when shape meets its limits

The difficulty of registering a shape as a trade mark is particularly evident from two other decisions.

The first concerns Coca-Cola, probably one of the most famous examples in the world of recognisable packaging.


In 2016, the General Court of the European Union rejected an application to register a three-dimensional trade mark consisting of a Contour bottle without the characteristic grooves of the historic bottle.


In judgment T-411/14 , the General Court held that the applied-for shape did not differ sufficiently from the standard bottles on the market and that acquired distinctiveness through use had not been demonstrated. The reputation of the classic bottle was therefore not sufficient to warrant registration of a variant.


The second precedent concerns Bang & Olufsen and a loudspeaker featuring a particularly original shape. In judgment T-508/08 of 6 October 2011 , the General Court upheld the refusal to register the shape as a three-dimensional trade mark, holding that it conferred substantial value on the product.


Here the paradox is even more evident: the very commercial importance of design helped prevent the shape from becoming the object of a potentially perpetual trade mark right.

These are two decisions based on different impediments, but they express a common principle.

A shape may be original, popular, recognisable, or commercially valuable without this automatically conferring the right to monopolize it as a trade mark.


What about the individual parts of a product? How far can protection extend?

The issue becomes even more delicate when the protection does not concern the overall appearance of the product, but only a portion of it.


European law also allows for the protection of product parts, provided the applicable requirements are met. For components of a complex product, the legislation also requires that the claimed characteristics remain visible during normal use.


Therefore, it is not possible to indiscriminately protect any internal shape of a car, perhaps hidden under the bodywork and visible only during maintenance operations, by invoking design rights.


A dashboard, a decorative interior feature or a graphical interface raises different issues from a concealed mechanical component whose shape is dictated by its technical function.

However, case law has recognized that protection can also concern specific portions of the bodywork.

In its judgment in Ferrari v. Mansory, Case C-123/20, of 28 October 2021 , the Court of Justice clarified that the disclosure of photographs of a car may also entail the disclosure of the design of one of its parts, provided that this part is clearly identifiable.


In other words, it is not necessary for each element to have been previously presented to the public as an independent product.


But it is also not permitted to arbitrarily cut out any portion of an object and claim exclusive ownership of it: the part must be visually identifiable through its own lines, contours, shapes, or other characteristics.


The theme is also relevant for automotive design, in which the line between protecting a specific shape and excessive fragmentation of exclusive features can become very thin.


Added to this is the potential overlap with copyright. The Court of Justice, in the Cofemel ruling (C-683/17), clarified that copyright protection requires an original intellectual creation and cannot depend solely on the aesthetic effect produced by the object.


A pleasing product isn't, by that very fact, a work protected by copyright. Otherwise, design studios might be tempted to have their artistic value certified directly by their sales departments, with easily imaginable results.


Back to the Defender: what will the judge have to decide?

Applying these principles to the dispute between Jaguar Land Rover and BYD, the problem takes on more precise contours.


It is not enough to say that the two vehicles look alike. The court must first identify the particular registered designs relied on by Jaguar Land Rover, determine their scope of protection and compare them with the actual appearance of the Ti7.


The overall similarity is certainly a significant factor. But so are the differences in the headlights, body connections, A-pillar layout, wheel arches, and proportions between the various volumes.


Above all, the court must distinguish stylistic features that contribute to the design's individual character from those already familiar in the sector.


An original combination of common elements may be protectable. However, identifying individual shared characteristics is not enough to conclude that two products necessarily produce the same overall impression.


A further aspect deserves attention: for registered designs, establishing infringement does not necessarily require demonstrating that the competitor has materially copied the original design.


The case has also been accompanied by the hypothesis that BYD dismantled and analyzed a Defender to study its design solutions. This accusation remains to be proven, but it does not coincide with the issue of design infringement.


Technical analysis of a competing product is not, in itself, illegal. The legal issue changes if patents, trade secrets, or other rights are violated, or if products are manufactured that fall within the scope of a protected design.


And it changes again when you invoke the protection of an unregistered design, which, unlike a registered design, protects against copying and not against a truly independent creation.


These are distinctions less immediate than a photographic comparison, but essential for seriously evaluating the controversy.


The first judicial decision: the problem of evidence

The affair has meanwhile produced a first significant measure.

On 11 November 2026, the Court in The Hague lifted an evidence seizure that Jaguar Land Rover had obtained the previous August at two Dutch BYD sites.


The measure allowed for the acquisition and preservation, through judicial officers and custodians, of a very extensive documentation: projects, computer files, company communications, commercial information and materials relating to the development and market launch of the Ti7.


The judge observed, however, that JLR had not shown that the seized documents were required to prove design infringement; their stated purpose was chiefly to determine its alleged extent and quantify damages.


Since the Ti7 was not yet marketed in the European Union, a merely future infringement could not justify, in the circumstances of the case, such an extensive acquisition of documentation intended to quantify damage that had not yet occurred.

The seizure was revoked and the destruction of the stored data was ordered.

The decision ( Rechtbank Den Haag, 11 November 2026, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33114 ) concerns the evidentiary instrument, not the merits of the design dispute.


Provided the necessary legal conditions are met, Jaguar Land Rover may still seek an injunction against future marketing. The merits of the design dispute remain open.


This point also has a systematic interest: the protection of industrial property cannot automatically justify extensive access to a competitor's confidential information. The exercise of exclusive rights must also be compliant with the principles of necessity and proportionality of procedural instruments.


The problem that remains

The Defender–Ti7 controversy isn’t just about whether one manufacturer took inspiration from another.

It addresses a structural problem in intellectual property law: protecting investments in design without excessively restricting competitors' freedom to develop products belonging to the same sector and with the same design language.


The European system seeks to maintain that balance through different rights with different requirements: patents for technical inventions, design rights for a product's appearance, trade marks for signs identifying commercial origin, and copyright for original intellectual creations.


Forms may benefit from multiple protections, but this does not mean that the conditions required by each become interchangeable.


The Porsche case demonstrates that a highly commercially recognisable design may not possess sufficient individual character to warrant new registration. The Vespa case demonstrates that a shape can acquire, through use, an independent distinctive function. Bang & Olufsen reminds us that a product's aesthetic value can constitute the very limit to its trade mark protection.

The dispute between JLR and BYD fits into this difficult architecture.

To evaluate the outcome, it won't be enough to measure how similar the two cars are. It will be necessary to establish how much of that similarity actually belongs to Jaguar Land Rover's exclusive sphere and how much, instead, should remain available to competitors.


That distinction has long been part of industrial property law, and the growing convergence of product designs makes it increasingly difficult to apply.


Trade marks, design and licensing disputes

For licensing agreements, trade mark or design disputes, learn about NL's intellectual property practice or contact NL Studio Legale to discuss your case.

Comments


bottom of page