top of page

Direct Compensation: When the Innkeeper Checks His Own Bill — and the Lawyer Agrees

4 days ago
11 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

An Italian story of insurance, compensation, missing consultants, and rights we learned to give up without anyone asking.


There is an extraordinary Italian invention that deserves to be studied in economics, law, and perhaps even in some illusion courses.



It is called risarcimento diretto: Italy's direct motor-insurance compensation scheme.

Its operation, explained without too many technicalities, is quite simple.

A driver hits you. You're not responsible. Your car is damaged, and you may even have sustained injuries.


Logic would suggest that you should seek compensation from the person who caused the accident and their insurance, possibly seeking the assistance of a professional to protect your interests.

Too complicated.

We've invented something seemingly much more convenient: you contact your insurance company, which takes care of settling the damage on behalf of the responsible party's company, then regulating the financial relationships between companies.


Your insurance company opens the case. Your insurance company appoints the adjuster. Your insurance company assesses the damage. Your insurance company makes the offer.

You basically wait.

Magnificent.

There's only one small detail missing: who checks, in the sole interest of the injured party, that the compensation offered is actually what is due?

Oh, right. The system has thought of that too.

Insurance provides you with assistance.

In short, the innkeeper not only prepares the bill: he kindly offers to check that it is correct.

And to make the service even more efficient, some contractual conditions even stipulated that the customer would agree not to rely on an external professional.

The innkeeper evidently doesn't like accountants at his table.


1. How we arrived at this masterpiece

A little history is useful here, because the problem does not arise from the bad intentions of individual claims handlers.


Direct compensation, in its current form, arises from the 2005 Insurance Code and the 2006 regulation, which became operational in February 2007.


The stated objective was understandable: to simplify procedures, speed up payments, reduce claims management costs, reduce litigation, and encourage competition among insurers.

All very respectable goals.

In reality, however, cost containment can occur in at least two very different ways.

The first consists in making the procedure more efficient: less bureaucracy, fewer unnecessary steps, fewer delays, less avoidable litigation.


The second consists in reducing the overall amounts awarded or in transferring to the injured party costs that could previously have been compensated.

These are two very different economic outcomes, especially for those who suffered the damage.

And here a particularly interesting provision comes into play.

Article 9 of Presidential Decree 254/2006 establishes, in the first paragraph, that the insurance company must provide the injured party with informational and technical assistance, to allow them to fully exercise their right to compensation.

So far, so good.

The second paragraph, however, provides that, where the claimant accepts the insurer's offer, no fees are payable for professional assistance obtained by the claimant, save for medico-legal assistance relating to personal injuries.


The system, therefore, on the one hand assigns insurance the task of assisting the injured party; on the other, it introduces a provision that aims to exclude, in certain circumstances, the cost of external professionals.

A building of remarkable elegance.

First, we replace the independent consultant with the assistance of the payment processor. Then, we consider the cost of the independent consultant unnecessary, because the assistance is already provided by the payment processor.


It must be recognized that, at least from the point of view of the circularity of the reasoning, the result is admirable.

Unfortunately, there is a small problem, known to law for a few millennia: conflict of interest.


2. Your insurance company isn't your lawyer. Not even when they call you by your name.

Let's try to clear up a misunderstanding.

Insurance companies can be extremely honest, efficient, and even generous. There are trained adjusters, reliable experts, and companies that scrupulously fulfill their obligations.

But the company remains an insurance company.

Manages premiums, costs, reserves, claims and financial relationships with other companies.

In direct compensation, the damage is settled on behalf of the responsible party's company, within a compensation system between insurers.


For this reason, it does not become an independent body responsible for exclusively representing the injured party.

It is a distinction as elementary as it is systematically forgotten.

Let's take an example.

You've been in an accident. The damage to your car is estimated at €4,000.

Who decided that there are 4,000?

An expert appointed by the company.

Who decides to make you an offer of 4,000 euros?

The company.

Who verifies whether the repair, any further damage, the economically demonstrable technical downtime, the possible loss of commercial value and all other compensable consequences have been correctly considered?

Always the organization of the company.

It may be that the 4,000 euros are absolutely correct.

But it may also be that the compensable damage is greater.

And how should the citizen notice this?

Consulting another insurance employee?

Rereading the report prepared for the insurance?

Or asking the same person who offered him 4,000 euros if, by any chance, it wouldn't be better to pay 6,000?


It's not impossible that it could happen. But it doesn't exactly represent the ideal model of independent control.


A consultant chosen by the injured party performs a different role: he verifies the damage in the interest of the person who suffered it, not within the economic framework of the person who must settle it.


And this difference doesn't disappear with a faster IT process, a well-designed application, or a particularly kind claims handler.


3. The real stroke of genius: convincing the injured party that his lawyer is an unnecessary expense

The most interesting part of the story concerns legal assistance.

Anyone who has ever dealt with road accidents knows the answer.

“It's a direct compensation claim, so legal costs aren't recoverable.”

A sentence uttered with the confidence we would normally reserve for the force of gravity.

The injured party, understandably, becomes discouraged.

Why should he pay for a lawyer if the company tells him he won't get reimbursed?

And here the mechanism produces a potentially extraordinary effect: there is no need to formally prohibit the use of independent professionals.

Just make it economically unviable.

The consequence is that citizens may forgo having their compensation verified just when they most need to know whether the assessment they received is correct.


Of course, a professional is not indispensable in every accident. Nobody suggests that trivial property damage, promptly acknowledged and properly compensated, must invariably generate a lawyer's fee payable by the liable party.


But there is a considerable legal distance between this and the claim that legal assistance is always superfluous.

And above all, there is some news that some companies seem to have some difficulty disclosing.

The Court of Cassation has already rejected the proposition that legal fees are automatically irrecoverable in direct compensation cases.


With ruling no. 11154 of May 29, 2015, the Supreme Court clarified that what matters is the actual need for assistance and the causal relationship between the accident and the professional expense.


Where the case is complex, or the insurer fails to provide the assistance required of it, reasonable legal fees may form part of the recoverable loss.


If, however, the intervention is objectively superfluous, there is no reason to pass the cost on to the responsible party.

A perfectly reasonable solution.

So reasonable that it seems almost revolutionary compared to the much simpler formula according to which "the CARD does not pay lawyers".


4. The client signed. So what? Did he also sign the suspension of the Civil Code?

At this point comes the other big argument.

«But the customer signed a contractual clause.»

So what?

Signing a contract does not automatically make every clause it contains valid.

This should be a fairly familiar concept, at least to those who deal with law.

Yet, in insurance matters, it sometimes seems necessary to remember it.

In 2016, the Italian Competition Authority (Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato) investigated clauses used by Allianz in its car insurance policies.


The mechanism was interesting: a 3.5% discount on the premium in exchange for a commitment not to entrust the management of the damage to legal professionals and to preliminarily resort, in certain disputes, to joint conciliation.


In case of violation, a penalty was foreseen: initially 500 euros, then 20% of the compensation, up to 500 euros.

A deal.

You save some money on the premium, but if you decide to seek legal assistance, you risk a financial penalty.


It's a bit like a restaurant offering a discount on the cover charge if the customer refuses to check the bill with the help of an expert. If they do check it, a penalty is imposed.


In Decision no. 26255/2016, the Italian Competition Authority (AGCM) found the clauses under examination to be unfair, citing in particular the restriction of consumers' contractual freedom to instruct professionals.

And the customer's signature?

It wasn't enough.

Because a unilaterally drafted clause does not become the subject of a true individual negotiation simply because the consumer has signed it separately.

Of course, not all insurance clauses are the same and each requires specific examination.

But the principle is very clear.

It is not enough to say "the contract provides for it" to demonstrate that a limitation of the injured party's rights is legitimate.

And there is another question, perhaps even more important.

The right to compensation for damages caused by an accident does not arise from the contract stipulated by the victim with his or her own insurance.

It arises from a tortious act.

Can we really assume that a form signed before an accident automatically cuts down a future tort claim, even where the costs of independent assistance prove necessary?

This is a very serious legal question.

It deserves more in-depth answers than a simple "the customer signed."


5. The surprising truth: nobody is obliged to sue their own insurer

And here we reach the point that ought to change how we handle these claims.

Because, by constantly presenting the procedure as the only possible solution, we have ended up considering it as such.

But it isn't.

In judgment no. 180 of 19 June 2009, the Italian Constitutional Court clarified that the action under Article 149 of the Insurance Code against the claimant's own insurer is an additional option, not a compulsory substitute for the ordinary claim.


The Court's distinction could hardly be clearer: the injured party may, but is not obliged to, bring that action.

And retains the right to take action against the person responsible and his insurer.

Let's think about it.

The system was presented as a tool to increase citizens' protection opportunities.

Not to diminish them.

Not to force him to use only one path.

Not to give his company exclusive power over the management of the compensation claim.

And certainly not to transform the exclusion of professional assistance into a general principle of civil liability.


An important qualification: the Constitutional Court recognised the availability of alternative judicial actions. It did not abolish the requirements governing pre-litigation claims, accident notifications or the procedural prerequisites to suing under the Insurance Code.


Accordingly, even where the direct compensation scheme could apply, the injured party may choose to pursue the ordinary action against the person responsible and that person's insurer.

A possibility that lawyers should be perfectly aware of.

And that citizens have every right to know before deciding how to proceed.


6. And what about us lawyers? Have we decided to retire early?

Here, unfortunately, a reflection is necessary that directly concerns our profession.

How many times have we heard a colleague say:

“It is a direct compensation claim. I won't take it on, because the insurer won't pay my fees.”

It's a sentence that deserves to be framed.

Possibly alongside Constitutional Court ruling no. 180/2009 and Supreme Court ruling no. 11154/2015.

Not because every accident necessarily requires a lawyer.

Not because every professional intervention should be reimbursed.

We have ended up confusing the difficulty of recovering our fees with the supposed non-existence of the client's right to independent representation.

These are two completely different problems.

The first concerns the cost and economic feasibility of the assignment, which we must explain transparently to the client.

The second concerns the protection of the injured party.

If the company disputes the reimbursement of our expenses, the solution cannot necessarily be to declare us useless and withdraw from the case.

Especially when there are case law rulings that allow us to challenge the indiscriminate denial.

And especially when the legal system maintains an alternative ordinary path.

We are lawyers.

Our work also includes interpreting the law, verifying its hierarchy, assessing the legitimacy of contractual clauses, and contesting legally unfounded claims.

Our job is not to treat insurers' operating instructions as if they ranked among the sources of law.

The CARD agreement is an agreement between insurers. It is not a law that forces a lawyer to forgo representing his client.


And the fact that a company does not want to reimburse an expense does not, in itself, demonstrate that that expense is not due.

Otherwise we could apply the same reasoning to any dispute.

The debtor doesn't want to pay?

Too bad. Apparently, that means the debt doesn't exist.

A surprisingly practical conception of law, but with some limitations.


7. So what should we actually do?

I believe that we need to radically change our approach.

As lawyers, we should stop considering direct compensation the automatic path for every claim that falls within its scope.


The initial choice should be different: verify the injured party's specific interests and prioritize the ordinary procedure against the responsible party and their insurer, exercising the relevant action when deemed appropriate.


That entails a properly addressed letter of claim and compliance with Articles 144, 145 and 148 of the Italian Insurance Code, without neglecting the notification of the accident to the client's own insurer and the other applicable requirements.

It does not mean that the ordinary procedure will always bring in more money.

It means avoiding automatically relying on a mechanism just because it has become a habit.

And when the company invokes a clause that excludes or penalizes professional assistance, we must request the text, verify its validity and effects, and contest it when the conditions are met.

Most importantly, we must document the activities we have actually undertaken to protect the customer.

The need for independent advice must be demonstrable, not simply proclaimed.

As for citizens, the message should be even simpler.

After an accident:


  • report the accident regularly, keep the evidence and do not rush to sign final receipts;

  • do not confuse the insurance adjuster with an independent adjuster who works exclusively for you;

  • before accepting an offer, check that all damages that can actually be compensated have been considered;

  • Ask a trusted professional what procedures are available, what the costs of care are, and when these costs can be recovered;

  • Don't assume a contractual clause is automatically valid just because you signed it.


The decision must be informed.

Not taken out of habit.

Nor is it due to the fear, perhaps unjustified, that any professional assistance would necessarily have to be paid for by the injured party.


8. The question the system should answer

After nearly twenty years of direct compensation, I believe it is appropriate to return to the initial question.


Who really benefits from a system in which citizens are led to believe that independent control over their compensation is superfluous?

If the result is simply a quicker, fairer, and less expensive claims settlement, then so be it.

But if part of the savings comes from the injured party refusing to verify the completeness of their credit or personally incurring necessary professional expenses, the judgment changes radically.

Because in that case we have not eliminated an unnecessary cost.

We've just changed the subject that tolerates it.

And we have potentially weakened the position of those who should be protected.

The point is not to argue that every direct compensation produces an economically disadvantageous outcome. Serious comparative data would be needed to demonstrate this.


A procedure designed to simplify claims settlement cannot, through contractual terms or claims-handling practices, become a means of discouraging independent scrutiny of the damages assessment.

Even more so when the law recognizes an alternative.

This is why I think the time has come for an information campaign aimed first and foremost at citizens.

And, immediately after, to the lawyers.

We must remind citizens that compensation is not a courtesy from the insurance company, but a right.

We must remind our colleagues that an agreement between companies is not a source of law superior to civil liability, the Consumer Code, or the Constitution.

There is no need to declare war on insurance.

It is sufficient to begin to rigorously exercise the tools that the legal system already provides.

And above all, stop considering inevitable what is not inevitable.

Because direct compensation may be convenient, but the convenience of a procedure can't be paid for by sacrificing independent oversight.

And as for the innkeeper, we will gladly continue to frequent his restaurant.

We simply reserve the right to audit your account.

Even with the help of someone who doesn't work in the kitchen.

Key authorities: Italian Constitutional Court, judgment no. 180/2009; Articles 144, 145, 148 and 149 of Legislative Decree no. 209/2005; Article 9 of Presidential Decree no. 254/2006; Court of Cassation, judgments nos. 11154/2015 and 3266/2016; Joint Sections, no. 16990/2017; Italian Competition Authority (AGCM), Decision no. 26255/2016, case CV144.


After a road accident, you have a choice

For a legal assessment of liability, evidence and an insurer's settlement offer, learn about our work on road accidents and compensation or contact NL Studio Legale to discuss your circumstances.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page